On high schools competing in college tournaments
-
- Tidus
- Posts: 654
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 5:58 am
- Location: Richmond, VA
On high schools competing in college tournaments
I want to start a thread to gather opinions on whether or not some experienced high school teams could or should attend certain college tournaments. If so, which tournaments might be at an appropriate level, and which tournaments might welcome such teams?
- The Time Keeper
- Auron
- Posts: 1327
- Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:26 pm
- Location: Michigan
What's the difference between a college team beating or losing to another college team and beating or losing to a high school team of comparable skill?mhayes wrote:Personally, I'm vehemently against high school teams competing in college tournaments, regardless of their skill levels.
From the standpoint of the college team, I don't see what it would have to gain by defeating or losing to a high school team. It's a no-win situation.
-
- Tidus
- Posts: 654
- Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 5:58 am
- Location: Richmond, VA
Conversely, from the standpoint of a high school team, I suppose it's a no-lose situation.mhayes wrote:Personally, I'm vehemently against high school teams competing in college tournaments, regardless of their skill levels.
From the standpoint of the college team, I don't see what it would have to gain by defeating or losing to a high school team. It's a no-win situation.
- JohnAndSlation
- Wakka
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Wed Mar 15, 2006 11:41 pm
- Location: Park Ridge, IL
Agreed. Especially for people who plan to continue in college, it's a great way to get a toe in the water. Besides, it's a great way to learn and get better. Nothing teaches you how to play a game like losing to a good team.jbarnes112358 wrote: Conversely, from the standpoint of a high school team, I suppose it's a no-lose situation.
From the standpoint of pure skill, there isn't much of a difference of all.What's the difference between a college team beating or losing to another college team and beating or losing to a high school team of comparable skill?
However, to an outsider who doesn't know much of anything about the skills of either team, it just wouldn't look good if a collegiate team lost to a high school team.
That having been said, however, if a high school team is in need of experience and there are not many high school tournaments around, then I suppose it would be acceptable for them to play in a collegiate tournament.
Who is this mythical "outsider" that we have to worry about placating?mhayes wrote: However, to an outsider who doesn't know much of anything about the skills of either team, it just wouldn't look good if a collegiate team lost to a high school team.
I don't think good HS teams would have any problem with the ACF Fall or EFT questions. The majority of college teams stink, so depending on the locale they could do quite well.
- ASimPerson
- Rikku
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Sun Apr 13, 2003 12:14 am
- Location: San Jose, CA
- Contact:
I've definitely played a few HS teams that could beat some college teams back in the day. If you've got the skills, I say go for it. (Shameless plug: EFT is an open tournament, if any HS folks want to come. Oct. 8 here at GT.)
Last edited by ASimPerson on Fri Sep 29, 2006 1:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
- The Goffman Prophecies
- Quizbowl Detective Extraordinaire
- Posts: 1611
- Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2004 10:25 pm
- Location: Wichita, KS
I was a member of one of 8 teams that lost to TJ when they played at Buzzerfest back in '04. I don't think there's any outsider to placate here, just perhaps a bruised ego.
I'm all for the competition. If high school teams want to join college events, I see no reason not to allow them; everyone gains from having additional competiton, even if it is from people who were just hitting puberty when you graduated high school.
I'm all for the competition. If high school teams want to join college events, I see no reason not to allow them; everyone gains from having additional competiton, even if it is from people who were just hitting puberty when you graduated high school.
Dan Goff
HSQB sysadmin
Virginia Tech '13
South Carolina '15
and a couple other places
Not Thomas Dale HS
STAAATS
HSQB sysadmin
Virginia Tech '13
South Carolina '15
and a couple other places
Not Thomas Dale HS
STAAATS
- ValenciaQBowl
- Auron
- Posts: 2558
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 2:25 pm
- Location: Orlando, Florida
Valencia's Delta Burke tournament this November will likely end up featuring a couple hs teams, as we won't fill up with CC teams (I allow CCs the first chance to fill all slots, and then am happy to open it to hs teams). As that tournament is the first competitive QB experience for more than half of the CC players in the field, I'll expect the hs teams to be in the playoffs. Generally it's going to be the QB experience that sets teams apart, not what types of classes they've taken (at least for a juniorbird tourney).
- grapesmoker
- Sin
- Posts: 6345
- Joined: Sat Oct 25, 2003 5:23 pm
- Location: NYC
- Contact:
The only good reasons for not allowing a good high school team to play against collegiate opposition have to do with maturity issues and supervision. I don't want some outraged biddy getting on my case because I sprinkled a few random "bullshit"s and "assclown"s in my packet. As long as parents and annoying coaches don't bother the TD, it's just another team as far as I'm concerned.
I think it's an excellent idea, Dr. Barnes, especially for a team like yours. I've read at several of UMD's college tournaments recently, and I quite frankly thought that some of my better teams could have been competitive with a few of the college teams there.
That's certainly not the case right now, and I don't think my present team would gain anything from the experience at this time. But your team is a much more knowledgeable team than mine. College tournaments will help your team because they'll be playing better opponents, because they'll hear a broader range of clues, and because they'll simply be playing more games.
Jerry makes a good point, however, that some of the questions have very adult material in them. So if your students or parents would have an issue with that, then you should probably check with the organizer regarding question content so you can decide whether the particular tournament would be acceptable.
A further point to consider is that there's overlap between NAQT D2 and IS series packets. Playing on one series may prevent you from playing on part or all of the other series.
That's certainly not the case right now, and I don't think my present team would gain anything from the experience at this time. But your team is a much more knowledgeable team than mine. College tournaments will help your team because they'll be playing better opponents, because they'll hear a broader range of clues, and because they'll simply be playing more games.
Jerry makes a good point, however, that some of the questions have very adult material in them. So if your students or parents would have an issue with that, then you should probably check with the organizer regarding question content so you can decide whether the particular tournament would be acceptable.
A further point to consider is that there's overlap between NAQT D2 and IS series packets. Playing on one series may prevent you from playing on part or all of the other series.
John Gilbert
Coach, Howard High School Academic Team
Ellicott City, MD
"John Gilbert is a quiz bowl god" -- leftsaidfred
Coach, Howard High School Academic Team
Ellicott City, MD
"John Gilbert is a quiz bowl god" -- leftsaidfred
- Skepticism and Animal Feed
- Auron
- Posts: 3238
- Joined: Sat Oct 30, 2004 11:47 pm
- Location: Arlington, VA
-
- Lulu
- Posts: 61
- Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 4:09 pm
- Location: Yale University
While I doubt it's really "illegal," most states with any sort of bureaucratic tie-ins between quizbowl and high school activities associations would restrict colleges and high schools from playing each other. By the same logic, middle schools can't field a team in a high school tournament. A lot of it is eligibility stuff...some guy at college can't play for a high school team and vice versa. Also, a high school basketball team would never play a college team or NBA team, and that mindset is applied to quizbowl when there's some sort of HS state umbrella organization.Bruce wrote:Believe it or not, this is illegal in Illinois. I have no clue why.
- Matt Weiner
- Sin
- Posts: 8145
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2003 8:34 pm
- Location: Richmond, VA
NAQT college tournaments are restricted to collegiate teams in any case (i.e. they are not de facto "opens" like most independent events), so high schoolers would not be able to participate even if question issues were resolved.Howard wrote: A further point to consider is that there's overlap between NAQT D2 and IS series packets. Playing on one series may prevent you from playing on part or all of the other series.
- quizbowllee
- Auron
- Posts: 2180
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 2:12 am
- Location: Alabama
Actually, I often have my middle school players compete in high school events...MikeWormdog wrote:While I doubt it's really "illegal," most states with any sort of bureaucratic tie-ins between quizbowl and high school activities associations would restrict colleges and high schools from playing each other. By the same logic, middle schools can't field a team in a high school tournament. A lot of it is eligibility stuff...some guy at college can't play for a high school team and vice versa. Also, a high school basketball team would never play a college team or NBA team, and that mindset is applied to quizbowl when there's some sort of HS state umbrella organization.Bruce wrote:Believe it or not, this is illegal in Illinois. I have no clue why.
I have considered trying to get my high school team to a collegiate tournament. The logistics haven't worked out yet, though. Every time I have found a suitable college tournament to attend, there is a high school tournament on the same day. I would love to let me high schoolers play at UTC or ACF Fall, but I probably won't forego a high school tournament in order to do so. I do know, though, that I played a lot of college teams that my high school team would kill.
Of course, you could open a big-ass can of worms here. If you start allowing high school teams to compete in college events, that might become a very uncomfortable trend. Perhaps hosts should consider some type of criteria (I'm not sure what, though) for allowing a high school team to compete. You certainly don't want really bad high school teams competing in college tournaments.
Lee Henry
AP Lit and APUSH Teacher
Quiz Bowl Coach
West Point High School
President-Elect/Past President- Alabama Scholastic Competition Association (ASCA)
AP Lit and APUSH Teacher
Quiz Bowl Coach
West Point High School
President-Elect/Past President- Alabama Scholastic Competition Association (ASCA)
Lee, the thing is, bad teams won't do it. If a high school team is losing to other high schools, do you think they'd even consider playing college teams? As for the use of cusswords, porn and other things that aren't (and shouldn't, IMO) be found in high school packets, I think that the teams that go kind of know this beforehand.
- Skepticism and Animal Feed
- Auron
- Posts: 3238
- Joined: Sat Oct 30, 2004 11:47 pm
- Location: Arlington, VA
There are college teams out there who are just as bad as any bad high school team, and yet these are still allowed to show up to any college tournament they please.quizbowllee wrote: You certainly don't want really bad high school teams competing in college tournaments.
I'm not sure this would be necessary at all.
- No Rules Westbrook
- Auron
- Posts: 1238
- Joined: Mon Nov 22, 2004 1:04 pm
The really relevant point to be made here is how terrible most collegiate teams are. And, yeah, I don't see a floodgate of helpless hs teams muddying the waters. I'm all for good hs teams playing, especially if it'll help this whole retention thing. As for offensive content, incidentally, I'm against college tournaments not having it - if you don't throw in three or four things with potential to really piss someone off, you're liable to make all the wrong people happy.
-
- Auron
- Posts: 1350
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 11:12 pm
- Location: Vienna, VA
- Contact:
I lost to Andy Goss's TJ my senior year of college in 1997.MikeWormdog wrote:While I doubt it's really "illegal," most states with any sort of bureaucratic tie-ins between quizbowl and high school activities associations would restrict colleges and high schools from playing each other. By the same logic, middle schools can't field a team in a high school tournament. A lot of it is eligibility stuff...some guy at college can't play for a high school team and vice versa. Also, a high school basketball team would never play a college team or NBA team, and that mindset is applied to quizbowl when there's some sort of HS state umbrella organization.Bruce wrote:Believe it or not, this is illegal in Illinois. I have no clue why.
I have no problem with allowing exceptional HS teams to play in a college tournament, provided players, coaches and parents realize that certain material will be covered in college quizbowl and not HS quizbowl, especially in the Pop Culture arena.
There is no VHSL rule against Scholastic Bowl teams trying their luck. My VHSL contact was very impressed when I told him that TJ had finished second in a college tournament.
- Deckard Cain
- Rikku
- Posts: 279
- Joined: Fri Nov 18, 2005 3:42 pm
- Location: Ozark, Missouri